The Office: All Possible Scranton Strangler Suspects, Ranked

In the quirky world of The Office, the identity of the serial killer known as the Scranton Strangler remains a playful mystery that fans love to theorize about. Though the show reveals George Howard Skub as the strangler, that hasn't stopped fans from coming up with their own theories and ranking more likely suspects.

Here are all the popular Scranton Strangler suspects from The Office, ranked from least to most likely.

7. Todd Packer

Rude and insulting, Todd Packer is far from a beloved character, but while his antics might make him a workplace villain, his behavior does not necessarily indicate serial killer tendencies. However, Packer's penchant for shockingly inappropriate behavior and extreme lack of moral standards is well documented, leading some fans to suggest that these behaviors could be a smokescreen for darker tendencies.

Though Packer's disturbing obsessions and willingness to harm others, even if it is mostly emotional harm, raise intriguing questions, Packer's character serves primarily as a comedic antagonist, and there is no real evidence linking him to the crimes of the Scranton Strangler.

6. Robert California

The enigmatic former CEO of Dunder Mifflin, Robert California displays manipulative and sociopathic behavior throughout his time in Scranton. His failed marriages and obsession with sex hint at underlying frustrations, and his self-proclaimed titles underscore his eccentricity.

Also, given his extended stay in Scranton, it's plausible that he could be the Scranton Strangler, taking out his pent-up rage on the city's residents.

5. Mose Schrute

Dwight's eccentric cousin, Mose Schrute, although an unconventional choice as a suspect, has intrigued many fans. His unusual habits and lifestyle are marked by bizarre behavior, including a need for bedtime stories and involvement in Dwight's eccentric schemes.

The most compelling evidence is Dwight's message to his son, hinting at Mose's potential murderous instincts and desire to eliminate his nephew to claim Schrute Farms, while Mose's limited presence outside the farm and the farm's dark history add to the mystery.

4. Dwight Schrute

Dwight Schrute's penchant for guns, odd behavior, and occasionally dangerous pranks have always kept him on the suspect list. His devotion to Dunder Mifflin and Michael Scott suggests loyalty rather than psychopathy, but his impulsive nature and strong desire for power could theoretically lead to violent tendencies.

In addition, Dwight has extensive survival skills and is well-versed in various combat techniques. Some fans also believe that The Schrute Farm, owned by Dwight's family, could be used as a burial site for the Strangler's victims, given its remote location and Dwight's close association with it.

3. Creed Bratton

Creed Bratton's eccentricity and mysterious past make him an intriguing suspect, and his admission of multiple identities sparks curiosity about his true nature. His bizarre actions, including arriving at the office covered in blood, confessing to murder and identity theft, and fleeing during a murder mystery game, have added fuel to the fire.

Creed's arrest in the series finale adds another layer of mystery to his character, making him a compelling candidate for the role of the Scranton Strangler.

2. David Wallace

While not a conventional suspect, David Wallace's sudden departure from the corporate world leaves room for speculation. The timeline raises questions, as he was fired at the end of Season 5, which coincides with the introduction of the Strangler narrative in Season 6 following the arrival of Sabre.

We get a glimpse of David's post-Dunder Mifflin life, marked by personal upheaval following a divorce, possibly linking his hardships to a coping mechanism involving serial strangulation. It's worth noting that even David Wallace's actor playfully hinted at his character's capacity for such acts.

1. Toby Flenderson

One of the most overlooked and underrated characters on the show, Toby Flenderson's mundane exterior hides a darker, hidden side that has always kept fans guessing. Toby's strained relationship with his boss and divorce from his wife contribute to his pent-up frustrations, which could manifest in violent acts.

Toby is also too involved in the Strangler case, and his belief in George Howard Skub's innocence makes things worse. Also, Toby's visit to Skub in prison, which ends in an attempted strangulation, may have been due to Toby finally revealing his true identity, causing Skub, an innocent man, to lose his mind.