Peaky Blinders: 4 Unanswered Questions We Used to Turned a Blind Eye to

written by Benjamin Patel

reviewed by Louise Everitt

November 25, 2023 7:15 am

Peaky Blinders: 4 Unanswered Questions We Used to Turned a Blind Eye to — Image credit: BBC

Fans hope a Peaky Blinders movie can address at least some of these questions.

Peaky Blinders, the acclaimed crime drama set in Birmingham, has kept fans hooked with its intriguing plotlines and complex characters. However, there are some puzzles in the storyline that we've perhaps overlooked or turned a blind eye to.

1. What Happened to Polly's Painter, Ruben Oliver?

Introduced in season 3, Ruben Oliver, a charming portrait artist, managed to steal Polly Gray's heart. Their romance, however, seemed to vanish without a trace.

Ruben Oliver disappeared from the storyline after season 3, and his absence was never explained in the show. It's speculated that his departure was related to Polly's arrest and her subsequent changes. It seems Ruben did not remain by her side during her difficult times.

2. Is Churchill out of the picture now?

Winston Churchill's character, based on the historical figure, played a significant role in the earlier seasons, often intersecting with Tommy Shelby's plots. However, whether he still remains relevant or not in the story is unclear.

Peaky Blinders: 4 Unanswered Questions We Used to Turned a Blind Eye to - image 1

It is one of those questions fans hope the Peaky Blinder movie will respond (if it ever materializes).

3. Where is Jimmy McCavern?

Jimmy Mcavern, a major antagonist in the series, was last seen in season 5, where he was a significant stressor for Tommy Shelby, especially in the context of Tommy's declining mental health and the failed assassination plot against Oswald Mosley.

Peaky Blinders: 4 Unanswered Questions We Used to Turned a Blind Eye to - image 2

The fate or subsequent actions of Jimmy Mcavern after these events have not been detailed in the show, and it looks like a missed opportunity.

4. How Was Aberama and His Son's Location Discovered?

Regarding how Billy, the informant, could lead McCavern to Aberama and his son while they were camping, this detail remains a puzzling aspect of the show. Gypsies would typically not be easily tracked, especially Aberama.

Peaky Blinders: 4 Unanswered Questions We Used to Turned a Blind Eye to - image 3

However, the show does not provide a clear explanation of how McCavern could locate them in such a secluded setting. This part of the storyline might be chalked up to creative liberties or plot necessities, even though it doesn't align with the characters' established skills in staying hidden and mobile.