The Boys Theory: One Fan-Favorite Character Could've Secretly Been a Supe All Along

While superhumans are the focus of The Boys, it’s undeniable that the characters who don’t possess any superpowers are as interesting as supes.

Take Stan Edgar, for example, Vought's ex-CEO. He managed to captivate fans despite not having any superpowers. However, an intriguing theory was shared on Reddit that suggests Stan Edgar might actually be a supe himself.

According to the theory, Stan Edgar was initially intended to be the contingency plan for Homelander, the most powerful supe. The idea proposes that Stan's purpose was to take out Homelander if necessary.

Have you ever noticed how Stan always seems cool as a cucumber, even in the most messed-up situations? If Stan is a supe, this revelation might explain it all.

First, we know that Edgar adopted Nadia, despite knowing how powerful she is and that she killed her own parents and a bunch of other people. Maybe Edgar wasn’t afraid of her at all because he was sure that she couldn't harm him.

We also know that Homelander used to be intimidated by Stan Edgar, — he said it himself in one of the episodes. Homelander can feel a person’s heartbeat, and he knew that Edgar was never afraid of him. It is possible that Edgar’s secret superpowers are the reason for this confidence and fearlessness.

Considering Stan's complex relationship with supes, the revelation of his powers would undoubtedly cause major conflicts. We've seen his cold and calculated demeanor when dealing with individuals like Homelander, Stormfront, and Queen Maeve.

Now, with abilities that rival or surpass their own, Stan would be a force to be feared. He could challenge their authority, manipulate their actions, or even become a threat they need to eliminate.

Many fans supported the idea to see Edgar in a whole new way. Just imagine Homelander punching Stan only to realize he can’t do any harm to him. Homelander would be even more shocked than when Butcher blasted him with his laser eyes.

But on the other hand, Stan's greatest strength has always been his intellect and strategic thinking. Some fans think that a reveal of Edgar as a supe will take away the charm of the character.

Source: Reddit